I just installed my set of Icon leafs this week after putting ~40k miles on my Deavers. I would go with Icons hands down over Deaver. I'm running the Fox Factory 3.0's and Icon bumps as well.
Besides Deavers sheer lack of finish quality (spray paint), they just seemed too mushy and “disconnected” compared to the Icons. Also, the Deaver +3 HD’s that I was running didn’t have the weight carrying capacity that they should have. 2-300 lbs in the bed and it sat lower than stock. I ended up putting a 1” block in, and then it was about stock. Icons, same level without a block and without the included extra leaf. We’ll see if it settles out at all.
As far as finish, I don’t think that they’re powder coated. I could be wrong, but they are at least coated with some type of more rubbery undercoating stuff. Time will tell how it holds up. The U-bolts are plated unlike Deavers too. I think Deaver forgets that people live outside sunny California.
The Icon's come with a nice U-bolt centering plate too, so you don't have to bother with trying to remove and drill out the stock one to put on the Deavers (or just choosing to not run them.
On top of everything else, the configurability makes them a total win-win.
View attachment 115228
View attachment 115230
View attachment 115231
View attachment 115232