Cam Phaser/Engine Failure Reports

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Status
Not open for further replies.

royCfus

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2018
Posts
131
Reaction score
48
Location
Las Vegas
Hey everyone, I thought I would share my experiences as well.

2017 Raptor : build was Feb 2017
First oil change at 3k and used Amsoil + Filter
Im at 30k now. Lightly driven and hard occasionally because she's my road queen and IDGAF what other's say. The only dirt she sees is during hunting season.
I have a tiny rattle upon start up. At first, was told it was waste gates cycling. Drove 2 years with it. Did not affect performance. Never had an issue with my truck. Never got worse.

I took my raptor in two days ago to check that rattle again. They returned and said there was no issue. All I can do now is watch and see what happens and if it gets worse. The thing I really wanted to share was that I was told that OEM filter and blended synthetic oil was key for these engines. The oil ford uses with their filters have been tested with these trucks. He also told me that Ford specifically says no amsoil. Reason being is because of different oils produce different pressures. Some not enough, some too much. There has to be the right amount of pressure for the oil guides to work properly. I asked them to do an oil change and use the blended synthetic they recommend and a regular ford oil filter. (He said ford performance is not needed). I will see if the oil change will reduce or worsen my noise. And to repeat what other's have said, it's better to use ford oem parts so down the line when you have a warranty issue, there's no reason for them to turn you down. They might just want to make extra money to tell me all this and scare me away from amsoil, but I am also a believer in using OEM and engineered specific products. Saves me money too. I'll update what I hear tomorrow.
I have a 2017 and was told the same wastegate story as well. After two more oil changes it has 38k miles now so I made an appointment for them to check it out again, told me yesterday that its cam phasers. The sound isnt as loud an obnoxious as others I have heard. Never the less cam phasers it is :(
 

Turbo_lander

Full Access Member
Joined
May 3, 2019
Posts
165
Reaction score
138
Location
Wilmington NC
Just took mine in today. Had a few videos on my phone and the service adviser was like yup timing chain. He didn't even doubt it and gave me a 19 King Ranch Diesel as a loaner. They are going to get into it tomorrow and make sure. While it's there I asked them to look into at the 10spd for funky shifts.

One other thing I have them looking at is the BOV/Waste gate too. The BOV sounded weird the other day.
 

Fastback89

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2018
Posts
160
Reaction score
76
Location
Philidelphia
Hey everyone, I thought I would share my experiences as well.

2017 Raptor : build was Feb 2017
First oil change at 3k and used Amsoil + Filter
Im at 30k now. Lightly driven and hard occasionally because she's my road queen and IDGAF what other's say. The only dirt she sees is during hunting season.
I have a tiny rattle upon start up. At first, was told it was waste gates cycling. Drove 2 years with it. Did not affect performance. Never had an issue with my truck. Never got worse.

I took my raptor in two days ago to check that rattle again. They returned and said there was no issue. All I can do now is watch and see what happens and if it gets worse. The thing I really wanted to share was that I was told that OEM filter and blended synthetic oil was key for these engines. The oil ford uses with their filters have been tested with these trucks. He also told me that Ford specifically says no amsoil. Reason being is because of different oils produce different pressures. Some not enough, some too much. There has to be the right amount of pressure for the oil guides to work properly. I asked them to do an oil change and use the blended synthetic they recommend and a regular ford oil filter. (He said ford performance is not needed). I will see if the oil change will reduce or worsen my noise. And to repeat what other's have said, it's better to use ford oem parts so down the line when you have a warranty issue, there's no reason for them to turn you down. They might just want to make extra money to tell me all this and scare me away from amsoil, but I am also a believer in using OEM and engineered specific products. Saves me money too. I'll update what I hear tomorrow.
I have been using the blended Ford oil for many years without any issues, glad to here they said that to you
 

Crash45

Active Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2017
Posts
57
Reaction score
25
Took mine in again Tuesday. Showed them the video of the cam rattle. It has a small miss now too. They can feel the miss but can’t figure out whats happening. It’s not throwing codes or showing up on a laptop. They had the truck all week. They told me to come get it today while they discuss it with Ford engineers. Said they would be in touch and get me a loaner when Ford tells them how to fix it. Had them change the oil and they didn’t charge me. I told them I’ll pay now, and they said we can settle up when you come back to get it fixed. That’s a first for me...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Turbo_lander

Full Access Member
Joined
May 3, 2019
Posts
165
Reaction score
138
Location
Wilmington NC
Took mine in again Tuesday. Showed them the video of the cam rattle. It has a small miss now too. They can feel the miss but can’t figure out whats happening. It’s not throwing codes or showing up on a laptop. They had the truck all week. They told me to come get it today while they discuss it with Ford engineers. Said they would be in touch and get me a loaner when Ford tells them how to fix it. Had them change the oil and they didn’t charge me. I told them I’ll pay now, and they said we can settle up when you come back to get it fixed. That’s a first for me...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I wouldn't have taken the truck back. And asked them to get a loaner until they figure out the problem. I know they hate it when a customer tells them what the possibility is (cam phasers and chain) but did you tell them? I told my adviser and he already knew what I was talking about and agreed with me. They still haven't diagnosed it yet (just dropped it off) but he is sure that is the problem and gave me a loaner.
 

RMB_Ryan

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Posts
143
Reaction score
158
Location
Wayne, NJ
Hey everyone, I thought I would share my experiences as well.

2017 Raptor : build was Feb 2017
First oil change at 3k and used Amsoil + Filter
Im at 30k now. Lightly driven and hard occasionally because she's my road queen and IDGAF what other's say. The only dirt she sees is during hunting season.
I have a tiny rattle upon start up. At first, was told it was waste gates cycling. Drove 2 years with it. Did not affect performance. Never had an issue with my truck. Never got worse.

I took my raptor in two days ago to check that rattle again. They returned and said there was no issue. All I can do now is watch and see what happens and if it gets worse. The thing I really wanted to share was that I was told that OEM filter and blended synthetic oil was key for these engines. The oil ford uses with their filters have been tested with these trucks. He also told me that Ford specifically says no amsoil. Reason being is because of different oils produce different pressures. Some not enough, some too much. There has to be the right amount of pressure for the oil guides to work properly. I asked them to do an oil change and use the blended synthetic they recommend and a regular ford oil filter. (He said ford performance is not needed). I will see if the oil change will reduce or worsen my noise. And to repeat what other's have said, it's better to use ford oem parts so down the line when you have a warranty issue, there's no reason for them to turn you down. They might just want to make extra money to tell me all this and scare me away from amsoil, but I am also a believer in using OEM and engineered specific products. Saves me money too. I'll update what I hear tomorrow.


Ford semi blend oil is absolutely horrible. The low or none existent additives required for heavy duty forced induction direct injection engines is horrible for the engine.

Ford doesn’t like 300k mile trucks and if they could make you buy new trucks at 100-120k they would probably force people. Laws don’t allow them to make people so they will not spend money to help them lose money. Not a smart idea.

These engines actually hate ford oil (specifically blended shmoo) and the viscosity at elevated temps yeah, there isn’t any. 90-100% of tear downs we do, if the customer ran factory oil, it is completely burned and baked on everything. The inside of engine at 10-50,000 miles is disgusting and burnt while we tear down customers built 100k engine to refresh the inside of the motor is spotless, zero oil staining in castings or parts. Not saying look at us or it’s because of us its this clean. We just care about engines we build and customers so oil isn’t an optional Budget cut for me.

When the proper oil is used and changed by customers long term, the engines look new inside for years. Sooo important

It is incredible what a proper sized oil cooler does and how much help and less wear and baked on spam we find in the engines. Oem oil coolers are a garbage item. One time use as well. Remove it’s replaced not reused!! Recycle for some not garbage. Oem cooler It’s small! She said anyway [emoji20]. Haha


About 40,000 BTU of cooling is needed for average running trucks not heavy off-roading even. 21 row double pass thru cooler is what we will use on street guys or parking lot pimping mall crawlers. Real use, totally new game, but oil temp is so critical.

Although oem oil filters are ok, if you race or rip in Arizona Texas Cali Baja or use it like you stole it, grab a race filter with same bypass and anti drainback. Like 100% more filtration and media so why not?



While I will confirm that Amsoil is good, this posts crazy long and if you like amsoil run a good viscosity not 5w30 in June July aug or 0w40. Also check pressure first time maybe adjustments to oil will be needed and won’t do damage to a thing

Regarding oil pressure comment. Winter, summer, fall morning or 230 pm, geographically where you live and temps and weather. All effect what oil should be used. And when too. My Canadian customers run 5w40 while Australian or Texan I spec to 5w50. Not one oil is right. One is right for you Though to benefit you where you live
Just sharing experience is all.

I do not think any business but ours relies on use of not good but top grade oil. I need engines working proper while ford needs service

Motorcraft semi syn oil will almost certainly promote long term and immediate accelerated wear, early failure possible, and the life or longevity of the engine as whole or specific + costly important internal parts like timing components will be significantly killed and have a reduced life. No good, dying early isn’t good, raptor fun, long time. Way cooler


Pic one- 20,000 miles and done. TBN was almost nothing when lab tested oil. These photos are of a clean engine not that bad too. Shmooo is shmoooo and shmoooo doesn’t form wedge on bearings, flow in and out vct solenoids and is really really bad.



Use this oil save trying several types
Lubrication engineers
Monolec 5w40
Gas and diesel specialty oil. All I will say, big increase in quality of this oil VS 99.9% of them all with one exception and that one is I think $29 per quart and I like a heavy wallet so no thanks. Try it, you will not regret doing anything better then you did prior in life or in the use of engine oil game. [emoji23]

Lastly disclosure: I have No skin in oil game, don’t like paying for oil but have to use the best for customers. if you run Pepsi it’s your truck, just sharing experience we have and results. 300 analysis later ^^^ is best by far^^^

03367efc44613e0ac5c703789072d33c.jpg
8b6810206235a3f13a90da4efee5b16f.jpg28539fa62865c0877a1c97a7f054023d.jpgc37dac4523f9e77ac76a96ddd219d549.jpg6eec5721cbf85da0276ad704ba1b0b6f.jpg
 

RMB_Ryan

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Posts
143
Reaction score
158
Location
Wayne, NJ
2019 has same part number, and has had a failure rate since 2017. Ford doesn't have a new part number available that works yet. Ryan here is working on a fix since he identified the root cause as a Ford design problem.


major part number saying these are phasers is same but engineering numbers not. Also, if you hear a 2019 had an issue perhaps it is user error.

To be honest ___
All v6 dohc engines have timing issues. Standard all platforms GTR all of them. Locking vct will dog the low end torque but if a car is lock them and cams as big as possible

To your comment on my fix, we don’t do fixes, but our solution works so we have a direction to help prevent (not a fix or cure any and all issues including cancer and world hunger.). It works, now it’s moving to next phase. Do you want to test these or no truck?
 
Last edited:

RMB_Ryan

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Posts
143
Reaction score
158
Location
Wayne, NJ
Unless it isn't the part itself that is the problem, which evidence very much suggests is the case. And if I recall correctly, Ford subcontracts the cam phasers and chains....
To Melling and others yes


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

engine45

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2014
Posts
200
Reaction score
71
Location
South Florida
To RMB Ryan. I’m in hot n humid like hell south Florida. What weight oil would you suggest ? Ive been running amsoil signature series 5w30. And there top oil filter. My trucks a 2017 and use 93oc always. I don’t cheap out on oil but I’m curious about the monolec. If you could and have time could you make a quick list of suggestions?
 

OPT PRIME

Full Access Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Posts
486
Reaction score
275
There are a lot of Honda and Toyota V6s running around in cars, trucks and outboard engines with variable valve timing and ridiculously long service lives.

Ford went with a hollow cam shafts and smaller phasers to save on rotating mass. That lighter assembly will have more harmonics and if the pins are really the issue then that there is the source of wear and tear.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top