Well, I wasnt there, so I cant speak of what the culprit was. That said, I have met Jamaal, and many others at SVT, consider a couple good friends, and I think if there was room for them to grant a warranty repair, they would have done it.
If you read between the lines, its more a question of where do you draw the line if not here. At what point does it become abuse, and not failure under "normal" conditions. I think everyone should agree that there is a line "somewhere" that should be drawn. Going over speed bumps in your office parking lot and having a failure should be covered and this side of the line. Surely everyone would agree that a Evel Kneivel style 50 ft jump over 3 buses would probably be over the line, but even if you start to wittle that gray area down, I would imagine a consensus would never be reached. Offroading is a broad definition. In 2008 I did a Bullrun event in Texas where I drove my GT500 at 160+ mph for very long periods of time. Had I blown my engine, would that have been a normal condition for that car? I bet some would say yes and some would say no. I guess my point is this whole ordeal is a no win situation for Ford. I have taken my Raptor to some pretty gnarly places already, 10 days into ownership. I love it, and regardless of "if" there indeed is a weakpoint in the frame, the solution is to find a way to fix it and make it better ourselves for the application WE intend. Its Fords job to give us a base vehicle that can be tuned into whatever we can dream up, and honestly, just like the GT500 program, I think the SVT group has given us something our fathers and grandfathers never even could have comprehended in a truck.
I dont intend to come off as a homer here, but guys, 500-1000 in repairs is a weekend at the track for me. Why sweat the small stuff. Really, if you total your truck doing one of these events, you arent getting insurance to cover it, so if you cant afford to fix it, you shouldnt be doing it anyway. I had a cam sensor on a brand new GT350 tripping codes due to a faulty harness last year. Since I bought the 624 package, warranty voided. I had to drop 1400.00 on a car with 43 miles on it for something that had ZERO to do with a supercharger being added to a brand new 2011 GT. It sucks, I agree, and Ive been there done that, but most of us have aready done something to void the warranty on these trucks anyway, so isnt it moot?