There would be a major downside to this approach, you’d have just another TRX from a different brand. The Raptor has a decent off road reputation and cred, so anything that negatively affects the brand, eats into sales and permanently damages the company’s reputation, built on their most popular selling vehicle.
I think there might be some context confusion here. CoronaRaptor was saying that he expected the Raptor R to be a better offroad vehicle than the Raptor. My counter was that the Raptor R needed to have more HP than the TRX without being worse offroad
...than the Raptor. I should have clarified with the italics, but thought it was implied given context.
I do agree with you that the R has to be as good or very close to as good in offroad capabilities as the Raptor. It can't lower it's offroad capabilities to match the TRX....that's considering that offroad capabilities may or maybe be subjectively interpreted.
It’s going to have to be competitive with the Gen3 at every stage, and better in at least some regards. It cannot be significantly deficient anywhere. The Gen2 saved hundreds of pounds of weight, and gave up nothing in any category to the gen1. The Gen3 will likely / similarly be the equal or better to the Gen2. My concern around the v8 Rap is what will not only the extra weight up front, but, the beefing up they’re going to need to do to the drive train and suspension going to do to the handling off road.
Agreed, but I don't think there is much to worry about here. Ford made mods to suspension and such to accommodate a 37" tire, so it's likely they will do the same for the R. Of course, it's not all going to be perfectly equal, simply due to costs and physics of different setups. As an example, the 37 package has less travel than the 35. Could they have given it the same travel? Sure, but not with a lot of re-engineering and costs which probably would have resulted in other compromises.
So, they either have to be very close in price to the TRX OR offer significant reasons not to buy the TRX by way of advantages over it.
It needs to be a Raptor that matches or exceeds the TRX while still living up to Raptor standards.
But I do think CoronaRaptor has a point about the electric trend. It's not hard to imagine that the hard-ons for V8 power may wane a few years from now when a Lighting work truck is out running supercharged V8s in 0-60. Won't take long before some puts some aftermarket tires and suspension and does well offroad...for a short half day trip.