The more dealers I talk to the more they tell me to stay away from the Eibach if I can. So that means Perch, Geiser or entire assembly. (entire assembly not an option at the present time)
How much pre-load can you put on factory spring to gain lift before placing the shock out of ride zone? If it's possible to do that than a Geiser has got to be putting the shock way outside of the ride zone at 2.5 inches of lift, or am I missing something? People talk about this but it's never really answered. If putting preload on the springs is not the best option then why do all the leading manufactures have it as a standard option on all the after market options? I'm coming from a 1-ton diesel I drove for over 15 years so forgive me while I try to get my head around this.
Looking more and more like I'll go the Icon AAC, it will allow some adjustibility to decide if I need to actually get Geiser or assembly later on. For me I want the truck to have a slight rake.
I'm at work and can't drink, if I could drink I could figure this out.
I can’t speak to which perch collars puts the truck out of ride height and which don’t. I will say though that if 2.5 inches takes the shock out of the optimal ride zone then a lot of people have messed up putting on +2.5”collars or Geisers.
On the Eibach front, I’ve been running the Eibach spring for almost 20K miles now and a can tell you that it is not anywhere as bad as people make it out to be. Is the truck stiffer than stock? Yes, but that should be expected since it’s clearly stated by Eibach. But it’s not harsh in by any means. I still float over road imperfections and can comfortably cruse down the wash at 70+ mph. I think that is you talk to people who have the springs you’ll find that the stiffness of the ride is extremely exaggerated. I would urge you to take a look at Dude1782’s build thread and see all that he has done with his truck on Eibachs.
I personally would tell you that if you think your going to go to full on replacement later down the road then you should just get a collar for now skip past the Geisers. If you think your going to stay with stock shocks then go ahead and do either of the springs. You can’t go wrong with any of your choices unless you throw a spacer on top of the coil.
I’m sure somebody will disagree with my opinion but hey, maybe my 2 cent will help you and others come to a decision on what’s best for your situation.