Cam Phaser/ Engine Failure Poll

Have you had or have a cam phaser or engine failure on your Gen 2?


  • Total voters
    628

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Turbo_lander

Full Access Member
Joined
May 3, 2019
Posts
165
Reaction score
138
Location
Wilmington NC
[QUOTE It's not a lemon just because it takes a long time to fix it. I'd ask for a loaner. That way you can at least put miles on something else for three months. They'll want to get your truck fixed ASAP to get the loaner/rental back too. Although if you really do want to get it lemon'ed research the laws of your sate carefully. Taking a loaner/rental may disqualify you from the lemon process- that happened to a Gen II owner here a year or so ago.[/QUOTE]

Your right but under the Magnous-Moss Warranty Act isn't just about the length/time of repairs but also for mulitple repairs which take up personal time and added stress of owning the vehicle I have had. Sync, Panoroof, Transmisson (shifts), Intercooler pipe (broken), and Eco Rattle (cam phasers) are all things I have had to take the truck in for and I have only had 6 weeks (tech 3 because it has been the shop for 3 of the those 6 weeks). I literally just made the first payment and don't even have my truck.
 

WraptorBoy

Active Member
Joined
May 20, 2019
Posts
138
Reaction score
47
Location
US
You have literally become a Ecoboost cheerleader.

If multiple people have had multiple repair attempts at low mileage, there are clearly issues. Just because yours isn't having issues doesn't mean there is not a problem. A "problem" engine can be reliable for 99% of the people. Sounds pretty good huh? That leaves 1 in 100 buyers with a major problem. That's a lot. No, I don't think it's anywhere near 20% like the poll shows, or even 5%, but it's way more than the typical Ford engine.

You poo-pooing the issues doesn't change the fact that Ford dealers are tearing into these engines at low mileage to replace cam phasers, often times more than once. You know, the same dealers who can never hear a rattle or duplicate any problems- yet somehow it's bad enough for them to get Ford to approve warranty work on the engine timing components.


The only cheerleading he does is trying to prevent people from going off half cocked thinking every 3.5 ecoboost is going to fail. Anyone who reads every post in this thread, and has a level head, is using this thread as a source of info and probably as a starting point to decide whether they will buy the Raptor. As mentioned several times before, people tend to read/write one thing and fly off the handle about it because they generalize... exactly what you did in your post. And, as stated many times, people tend to report their issues to see if others are seeing the same to get an idea if it's only their truck or everyone's and that's what comprises a thread like this: everyone posting a similar problem so it seems like a huge issue.

No one knows if they buy a Raptor if they will have the issue. If yes, unfortunately, it will be too late. As an example, if you bought a 2015 Lexus IS350 you'd have been SOL as well and would have had to have the dealer rip into your brand new engine and fix an internal issue.

Anyone who reads the poll above and thinks that is the end all be all of this issue is an idiot. As mentioend before, there are around 300K F-150s (25k of those are Raptors) made a year with this engine.

If this is a cam phaser epidemic, then Ford should issue a recall/TSB and prevent future vehicles from having it... unless there is a conspiracy to hide it. If there isn't, then it's been localized to bad parts and hopefully they aren't using the bad parts anymore. Again, no one but Ford knows. So far it seems to be mainly 2017-2018. Then again, it doesn't show up until 25K miles so 2017 and newer is really too soon to tell. Anything before 2017 is Gen 1 and not applicable because it was either the V8 or the gen 1 ecoboost, neither of which can be compared to the current gen 2 Raptor or ecoboost 3.5.

Everyone needs to do their research and decide on their own if they will risk having the issue and what to do if they do have it.

So far, the NHTSA has no recalls relating to this issue. And read the entire recall. They always specify the number of vehicles and period of when they were affected. There are only simple things like the doors opening while driving LOL.

Bottom line: the more real info we have of empirical evicdence, the better decisions others can make, hence the reasons for these forums so keep it coming!
 

smurfslayer

Be vewwy, vewwy quiet. We’re hunting sasquatch77
Joined
Dec 16, 2016
Posts
17,717
Reaction score
27,360
You have literally become a Ecoboost cheerleader.

If multiple people have had multiple repair attempts at low mileage, there are clearly issues. Just because yours isn't having issues doesn't mean there is not a problem. A "problem" engine can be reliable for 99% of the people. Sounds pretty good huh? That leaves 1 in 100 buyers with a major problem. That's a lot. No, I don't think it's anywhere near 20% like the poll shows, or even 5%, but it's way more than the typical Ford engine.

You poo-pooing the issues doesn't change the fact that Ford dealers are tearing into these engines at low mileage to replace cam phasers, often times more than once. You know, the same dealers who can never hear a rattle or duplicate any problems- yet somehow it's bad enough for them to get Ford to approve warranty work on the engine timing components.

Literally, less than 10 posts back-

There’s a problem with some trucks. Dealer service departments have sometimes not acquitted themselves well in dealing with this, and some of the other problems. Parts availability has been an ongoing challenge for pretty much any Raptor problem.

There are, at least according to posts here, dealers that refuse to do anything about the “start up rattle” because no codes are being thrown but then again, some of these ‘start up rattle’ cases are benign, and in all likelihood will never be symptomatic, because with this type of system there’s some rattle at startup all the time, some quieter than others and again many will never be a problem.

We’re just quibbling over numbers... and your desire to make this thread “a thing”.

The poll and responses in this thread indicate a far higher failure rate than 0.05%, but whatever. Standing by my prediction 100%. This thread will have LEGS.
 

Mapleman

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2016
Posts
166
Reaction score
73
Location
Western mass
So got my truck back from the dealer that my co worker use to work at a recommendation me too. They basically did nothing for me. Said my ac belt was shredded. Replaced that and test drove. I still positive I need phasers again. So I guess I’ll wait till she comes apart.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

WAC

Member
Joined
May 1, 2019
Posts
11
Reaction score
1
Location
Dallas
Wish I would have known about these issues before I purchased a few months back.
However, my father-in-law has a 3.5 Eco and it has 150k miles on it with no issues and he pulls a horse trailer.
My neighbor has 80k on his 2015 3.5 Eco with no issues. These two people swear by these motors. So all of these mixed reviews with most being good are very interesting. Is it mostly Raptors because they are more performance oriented and a lot of folks hot rod them a lot?
 

EricM

FRF Addict
Joined
May 11, 2016
Posts
3,574
Reaction score
3,327
Location
OHIO
Wish I would have known about these issues before I purchased a few months back.
However, my father-in-law has a 3.5 Eco and it has 150k miles on it with no issues and he pulls a horse trailer.
My neighbor has 80k on his 2015 3.5 Eco with no issues. These two people swear by these motors. So all of these mixed reviews with most being good are very interesting. Is it mostly Raptors because they are more performance oriented and a lot of folks hot rod them a lot?

It's not that the engines are junk or that they are all unreliable. Far from it. The issue is they have a higher failure rate than Ford's other engine choices. You simply do not hear of these cam timing problems on the 5.0L Coyote or the 6.2L V8, or any other Ford engines. It's a recurring issue on the TT V6 EB engines though. Both on the Gen 1 engines and now on the Gen 2 engines.

Ford Tech on YouTube has a series of videos on fixing the Gen 1 EB timing problems. He also has a series of videos on fixing the 5.4L 3V VVT solenoid issues. Both engines have issues that are common enough to need a multipart step-by-step repair process to be documented so people can do it themselves. We can all talk about anecdotal testimonies, but when the guys who fix them for a living say there are issues with them- then there are issues with them. Give it a decade and he'll have a series of videos on fixing the Gen 2 EB timing issues. Right now, the Gen 2 EB engines are still low mileage, fixed under warranty and therefore the failures are kept "in house and under wraps" for the most part. Once the trucks go out of warranty and people have to pay out of pocket to fix the issues that occur more frequently at high miles, the reputation of the engine changes quickly.
 
Last edited:

RaptorLF18

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2018
Posts
104
Reaction score
41
Location
Minnesota
What do you think this sound is? I dropped my 2018 off at the dealer today. When I played the video for the service writer, he got me a rental and an appointment right away. For what it's worth, I posted this video in another discussion inadvertently. I deleted it and brought it here. Don't want anyone thinking I'm trolling. New to this.

 

fur_pig

Full Access Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2015
Posts
259
Reaction score
143
When I worked at Ford when the 5.4 3v came out and had a lot of cold engine ticking/rattle on start up etc. we called it the trifecta as it needed a phaser, valve body and VCT solenoid per bank. Those phasers had a clock spring and an series of veins that depending on which side of the vein the oil was directed, would advance or retard the timing. Originally this was a get around from having EGR yet also a significant way to improve power. I don't work there anymore but the noise was not detrimental to reliability per say but was worsened by poor maintenance, low oil viscosity, restrictions in the valvebody etc. The 3.5 ecoboost just was coming out when I left there but the fundamental operation of the VCT at that time on the 3.5 was the same as the 4.6 and 5.4 3v. I guess I just wanted to voice my 2 cents that the rattle/tick on start up isn't as life or death as this thread may make it seem. My 2018 doesn't do it but I'm sure if it did I'd be annoyed too.
 

NORCAL SS

Full Access Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2019
Posts
141
Reaction score
53
Location
Willow Creek
What do you think this sound is? I dropped my 2018 off at the dealer today. When I played the video for the service writer, he got me a rental and an appointment right away. For what it's worth, I posted this video in another discussion inadvertently. I deleted it and brought it here. Don't want anyone thinking I'm trolling. New to this.

Sounds like what mine had. They bought it back
 
Top