Nostalgia is not going to artificially inflate the price, and neither is a baseless opinion. Cylinder count is not indicative of performance. That’s like saying a 305 Camaro should be worth more than a Gran National because it has a higher cylinder count. It makes zero sense.
Nostalgia, for whatever reason, can absolutely inflate the market price of a vehicle. Have you shopped for an older diesel platform lately? An H2 hummer? A GMT400 truck? 2 door k1500? Heck, even a low mileage gen1 is pulling crazy money at the moment.
I never said anything about cylinder count vs vehicle performance. Unless you meant market performance?
I don’t know where you live, but in my area, there are hardcore enthusiasts for trucks who absolutely refuse to ever own a v6 or 4-cyl truck for the sound alone.
And I said the market would be hotter for gen1 vs a gen2, IMO. Nothing about performance, price, or actual value. I just see them being more sought after, that’s all. Gen 2 is a bad ass platform, and better than a gen1 in just about every measurable way, except there are guys like me who don’t care about those measurable ways, and smile whenever they cold crank in the morning, and enjoy the driving experience.