Just looking into winter tires as well. Really would like to go with Blizzark DM-V1 winter tires. But the largest size I can find is 33".
Wonder how a 33" tire would look on the raptor. Probably acceptable.
I have personally driven and compared DM-V1, BFG AT+MTs, Trail Grapplers, Bridgestone Dueler AT Revo 2s, and a few street oriented tires on a 500awhp truck in different winter conditions. With the right air pressure all can fairly deal well in most winter conditions, however on ice they all fail; BUT the DM-V1s and anything studded.
On ice in the AT - class, I personally think the Revo2s are the best, and a class above the rest of the AT options. I also have driven the Duratracs and General AT ( however on another truck/size), and I would say that they are very comparable to the BFG ATs
For me I think I will choose between a Revo 2 in 34" or DM-V1 for a dedicated wintertire...otherwise stock BFG ATs should be more than fine and equal to most tires mentioned in this thread imho.
MT's in my opinion are dangerous in winter, whenever there is sheer ice. They might be super capable for deep snow and snow, but all other ATs do fairly well here as well.
Air pressure is the secret sauce to make most tires work somewhat in the cold.