I had this exact same thing happen to me in my old 2500. 16 year old kid with two half naked high school girls with HUGE melons in his car side swiped me.... I had a dent in my front fender but my tires destroyed his car. BRAND NEW VW still with dealer plates.
He accepted full responsibility, gave me his insurance and we parted ways. That afternoon, his mom calls me up SCREAMING about how i hit her sons car. Apparently his story to mom and dad was something different. We both had statefarm and since there was no police report (stupid me)... they said they couldnt take a side and told us both to pound sand.
Luckily I was only out a few hundred bucks... poor kid though! Here he thought for sure he was gonna be face deep in tity that afternoon!
Plus note for you: Thats a few G's in mods right there! AH YA! I keep praying someone will rear end my truck so I can get a new bumper lol