Amber up I say.....I bought from FRL (now Offroad Alliacne) for my '17 when the bezels were pre-order and had to fill out a paper form to get on the list. Jeff was very good at providing updates, etc. Been buying from them ever since. Ok not a fanboy....just the facts.
BTW, I tore a rubber gasket on the install....not sure how I did it....and Offroad Alliance sent me two new ones no charge. OK a little bit of a fanboy.
On the '17, I have KC light flex and set of Rigid Industries spot and flood dually lights + a BD ONX6. Great lights....no issues. Lights up the road real nice. I liked them so much I was going to move them over to the '20. Then I saw the ONX6+....blah, blah, blah...and convinced myself to go with all new lights and then sell the '17 as-is. I really just did not want to do double the work to disassemble to move to the '20.
Now I loved the OEM look of the RFL bezel so much I went with it again on the '20. But this time I went with all BD Squadron lights and S1's. Plus the ONX6+ and finally the S8. I calculated somewhere around a 50% increase in lumens not counting the S8....well that was my semi-flawed logic that made be spend more money.....was it worth it? Beat myself along the way until I fired them up....definitely yes. Have yet to take them out on a trail....but they are definitely going to be better.
What I really like is running all the ambers on the road. If you pull out in from of me then you are just blind or texting....looks great in my opinion. Wired the S1 and the amber on the S8 to the same switch.