Manual Shift = 4MPGs?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

BIRDMAN

Birdministrator
Joined
May 16, 2010
Posts
12,915
Reaction score
6,197
Location
Boston
I had an idea today. I frequently travel on roads where the speed limit is 35-40mph. For the sake of today's discussion, the speed limit on the road I traveled on for quite some time was 35mph. It's a long residential road with a few rolling hills and usually very light traffic. There are a lot of roads in the towns around me that fit this description.

I found myself cruising along in very light traffic around 40MPH and noticed that I was in 5th gear.

After a little fooling around I found that 5th gear runs from ~36mph to ~49MPH under light throttle while cruising.

I was getting decent fuel economy and wondered if being in 6th gear would help, hurt, or if the speed was too low to be in 6th and I would risk bogging down.

Well to answer the 3rd question, in manual mode if you fall below a certain speed in each gear the truck will automatically downshift. I found while in 6th gear in manual mode that the truck would shift in to 5th right around 36MPH which was consistent with the bottom end of 5th in "auto" mode. I suppose that is the point where the RPMs fall below what is acceptable to run in 6th.

So I performed a very short, very unscientific test that I would like to offer up for discussion.

I ran the same exact 2.5 mile length of road 2 times. 70*F, little or no wind. I set the cruise control at 40MPH for about 30 seconds each time prior to resetting the MPG readout.

I reset the MPG readout at the exact same spot both times, going the exact same speed (40MPH) in cruise control. I made sure I was clear of any traffic so I could run about 2.5 miles without any further input.

Test 1 was "auto" mode which stayed in 5th gear all but once when the truck briefly downshifted to 4th while going up the largest hill along the route. At a certain point I recorded the MPG and stopped the test.

Test 2 was manual mode set to 6th gear. The truck stayed in 6th the entire time and had no problem maintaining the 40mph speed. The truck didn't bog or shudder whatsoever going up the hill although I did notice a distinct change in exhaust note.

Below are the results of my short test:

Auto Mode:
IMAG0115.jpg


Manual Mode 6th gear only:
IMAG0116.jpg

:hmmm2:

I realize these were controlled conditions with no traffic, but if you travel on long stretches of road with light traffic frequently in the 40-45 mph range give it a shot! Post here if anyone else wants to conduct something similar.
 

SterlingE55

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Posts
252
Reaction score
64
Location
Houston
This is why I went from my 5 Star 93 perf tune back to stock. I got tired of having to switch to manual to get to 6th since I travel a 35mph road for 5+ miles to and from my shop. On the highway there's little difference between stock and the 5Star 93 perf tune.
 

banman12

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Posts
428
Reaction score
107
Location
Rochester, NY
Nice test Birdman. Thanks for the real-world feedback! Lol at first when I saw this thread I thought you were saying that you were showing 4MPG while driving in manual mode. Was gonna say, what the hell!
 

Squatting Dog

FRF Addict
Joined
Jun 1, 2011
Posts
8,602
Reaction score
4,103
Location
Kansas City, MO
I had an idea today. I frequently travel on roads where the speed limit is 35-40mph. For the sake of today's discussion, the speed limit on the road I traveled on for quite some time was 35mph. It's a long residential road with a few rolling hills and usually very light traffic. There are a lot of roads in the towns around me that fit this description.

I found myself cruising along in very light traffic around 40MPH and noticed that I was in 5th gear.

After a little fooling around I found that 5th gear runs from ~36mph to ~49MPH under light throttle while cruising.

I was getting decent fuel economy and wondered if being in 6th gear would help, hurt, or if the speed was too low to be in 6th and I would risk bogging down.

Well to answer the 3rd question, in manual mode if you fall below a certain speed in each gear the truck will automatically downshift. I found while in 6th gear in manual mode that the truck would shift in to 5th right around 36MPH which was consistent with the bottom end of 5th in "auto" mode. I suppose that is the point where the RPMs fall below what is acceptable to run in 6th.

So I performed a very short, very unscientific test that I would like to offer up for discussion.

I ran the same exact 2.5 mile length of road 2 times. 70*F, little or no wind. I set the cruise control at 40MPH for about 30 seconds each time prior to resetting the MPG readout.

I reset the MPG readout at the exact same spot both times, going the exact same speed (40MPH) in cruise control. I made sure I was clear of any traffic so I could run about 2.5 miles without any further input.

Test 1 was "auto" mode which stayed in 5th gear all but once when the truck briefly downshifted to 4th while going up the largest hill along the route. At a certain point I recorded the MPG and stopped the test.

Test 2 was manual mode set to 6th gear. The truck stayed in 6th the entire time and had no problem maintaining the 40mph speed. The truck didn't bog or shudder whatsoever going up the hill although I did notice a distinct change in exhaust note.

Below are the results of my short test:

Auto Mode:
View attachment 19651


Manual Mode 6th gear only:
View attachment 19652

:hmmm2:

I realize these were controlled conditions with no traffic, but if you travel on long stretches of road with light traffic frequently in the 40-45 mph range give it a shot! Post here if anyone else wants to conduct something similar.

I mentioned this on 3/21/2012....

http://www.fordraptorforum.com/f5/one-only-gas-mileage-thread-please-198/index29.html#post175782

Locking it in 6th gear really helps... (have flame resistant suit on)

-Greg (aka squatting dog)
 
Top