I've owned both. The major problems with the scabs were when you had anyone in the back seat that wanted to get out, you had to unbuckle your seatbelt, open your door, so they can open their back door, to exit. Also you need to have both doors open to retrieve anything out of the back. Pain in the butt! With the Scab no such issues. Plus, me personally, I do a lot of competition shooting and need the extra room in the back for my gear.