are their scenarios where a e tune wont be a able to replicate vs a dyno tune and vise versa?
From my experiences with both, the e-tune is more time consuming. On the dyno they wrap the tune up in one session usually. For my e-tune, the tuner sent me a base MAP and I had to go log data. For the STI I had it was a few pulls in 4th gear from 2500/3000 rpm to redline. Email each log and the tuner would make tweaks until it was perfect. My e-tune was ran very well.