Made the switch today from OEM Cast 35's to KMC Mesa Forged 17x8.5 +0 (23lbs) and OEM FP 37's. Suspension is stock 35 unmodified and no rubbing and fitment is spot on. Back is perfectly flush, front pokes maybe 1/2" which is slightly more than I'd like but manageable.
Couple Notes:
OEM Cast 17's and 35's weighed ~94lbs on my scale.
KMC Forged Mesa and OEM FP 37's weighed 91lbs. I think BFG specs for their OEM 37's are off. KMC Mesa verified at 23lbs so these tires are closer to 67lbs not 63lbs. This also accounting for TPMS sensor and balancing weight (10-14oz).
BIG thanks to Justin at Pacific Wheel for answering countless questions over the past few months and getting these wheels to me at lightening speed. You absolutely rock!