We...well some, remember when BMW started naming all "sporty" vehicles as their iconic M SERIES.
528I - M Package
750 - M package
328 - M Package
Without having the actual heart and soul of an M Series vehicle. I can understand the naming scheme being hated for the Bronco Raptor. There is only a few real M series vehicles, M1, M3, M5, and M6, same for the RAPTOR. There is only one RAPTOR.
this right here is true dilution and confusion for the consumer all at the same time.
It's totally logical and defensible on the logic. But people aren't logical. The entire pseudoscience of economics comes to grief on this one fact. The Raptor has incredible name recognition. It's iconic, one word, short and sweet, with a vivid image associated with it. From a branding standpoint, it's exactly where you want to be. No one really thinks about the Raptor as an F-150 except for a few pedantic car geeks. Trying to leverage that across product lines is risky because you risk losing everything you've achieved. When you have a family, F-150 Raptor, Ranger Raptor, Bronco Raptor, whatever, the consumer doesn't have a single vivid image in their mind any more. Instead they have a poorly imagined group of vehicles and a vague idea that "Raptor" means something about off road s**t. It's the very definition of dilution. The attempt to extend the halo often results in losing the halo altogether.
Ranger Raptor was a mistake, but at least they didn't compound it by selling it here. Bronco Raptor? Is it a Bronco? Is it a Raptor? WTF? Let's confuse potential customers and see how that works out. Let's make people say "F-150 Raptor" instead of "Raptor". Really? Ford is playing with fire. I sure hope they know what they're doing.
this does make a lot of logical sense, and really we dont know their true intention of slapping the name on these trucks. Is it lazy? Possibly. Is it creative? No, definitely not. Is it an attempt to group a set of vehicles together with a like minded look and functionality? Yes.
You know another halo trim that exists/existed for a long time that does the same thing? Any Type-R Honda. Yes, its a comparison of two different types of vehicles, but their marketing and naming convention directly reflects their capability. If you mention the word Type-R, any car geek will know its the absolute best version of a particular Honda (NSX, Integra, Civic, and to a lesser extent the Accord). I think the Raptor line/brand is trying to acheive the same thing. Now if Ford does what BMW/Merc/Audi/Lexus does and named their vehicles the way they do (examples: M/M-package, AMG/AMG package, RS/S-line, F/F-sport), then I would tend to wholly agree with you. However, I think that those makers have truly diluted their model names and the consumer suffers because they see badges that are similar, wheels that look alike, similar-ish aero kits etc...If Ford went and offered a so-called "Raptor Package" on a lower trim then this would be the equivalent to those lux brands, I guess the Tremor would be that pack, but at least its a different name!
Thats my 2 cents about all of this.