This actually happened to me. Bought a 2019 landcruiser “owners demo” but it was sold to me as new and first owner. Went to sell it this year and carfax showed damage to front left.Your numbers are pretty accurate...depends but close. But don't tell OP, he trusts the dealer that did this in the first place won't report to Carfax, so all is good Trust me when OP goes to trade and they find out bumper has been replaced and paint work he will be feeling the pain.
Was gonna sue their asses but carmax gave me 79k! Bought it for 75.5.