Hi MB, When I had my fender flares painted, the owner of the body shop offered to paint the reflectors for $50. He said, he has done it for years. They can do them as dark as you want. It looks much better in person. That bright orange was awful. I don't know where you live, but I'm sure any body shop can do it. I went to Ozzies in Loveland Colorado. - - Raptor Girl.